Virtually all dentists are intrigued when endodontic post-treatment radiographs exhibit filled accessory canals. Filling root canal systems represents the culmination and successful fulfillment of a series of procedural steps that comprise start-to-finish endodontics (Figure 1). Although the excitement associated with the so-called “thrill-of-the-fill” is understandable, scientific evidence should support this enthusiasm. Moving heat-softened obturation materials into all aspects of the anatomy is dependent on eliminating pulpal tissue, the smear layer and related debris, and bacteria and their byproducts, when present. To maximize obturation potential, clinicians would be wise to direct treatment efforts toward shaping canals and cleaning root canal systems.1
Figure 1. A post-treatment film of a mandibular first molar demonstrates the importance of shaping canals and cleaning and filling root canal systems.
|Figure 2. This animation supports the scientific evidence that shaped canals enhance the active exchange of irrigant into all aspects of the root canal system.|
Figure 3. The Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System (DENTSPLY Tulsa) combines a “Pack” handpiece for downpacking with the “Flow” handpiece for backpacking.
Figure 4. A post-op film of a maxillary second molar. Note the abrupt apical curvature of the palatal system, recurvature of the DB system, and the filled furcal canal.
Shaping facilitates 3-dimensional (3-D) cleaning by removing restrictive dentin, allowing a more effective volume of irrigant to penetrate, circulate, and potentially clean into all aspects of the root canal system (Figure 2). Well-shaped canals result in a tapered preparation that serves to control and limit the movement of warm gutta-percha during obturation procedures. Importantly, shaping also facilitates 3-D obturation by allowing prefit pluggers to work deep and unrestricted by dentinal walls and move thermosoftened obturation materials into all aspects of the root canal system. Improvement in obturation potential is largely attributable to the extraordinary technological advancements in shaping canals and cleaning and filling root canal systems.2,3 Schilder described the classic vertical condensation technique more than 40 years ago.4 Over time, a few different, yet similar, warm gutta-percha techniques have evolved.
This article will describe the Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System (DENTSPLY Tulsa) (Figure 3) and how to use this technology to perform the vertical condensation technique. The clinician is encouraged to read, visualize, and learn more about how to perform each and every procedural step that directly serves to influence filling root canal systems; this includes how to perform the other hybrid warm gutta-percha techniques using the Calamus technology.1,5
VERTICAL CONDENSATION TECHNIQUE
The objective of the vertical condensation technique is to continuously and progressively carry a wave of warm gutta-percha along the length of the master cone, starting coronally and ending in apical corkage (Figure 4). The physical and thermomolecular properties of gutta-percha are well understood and have been clearly described in a series of groundbreaking articles published decades ago.6-10 The content of these scientific articles provides insight, understanding, and reference for the clinical and technical description that follows. Although the author has previously described the vertical condensation technique,11,12 this article represents the most recent advances in how to perform the warm gutta-percha with vertical condensation technique.
CONEFIT AND PLUGGER SELECTION
Figure 5. These animations demonstrate the master cone fit to length and the master cone apically cut back based on the paper point drying technique.
Figure 6. Select the electric heat plugger (EHP) that will loosely fit through the straightaway portion of the canal and optimally to within 5 mm from the full working length.
Traditionally, a size medium nonstandardized gutta-percha master cone was selected and apically trimmed to fit snugly into the terminus of the prepared canal. The 6% taper of these master cones, as compared to the 2% taper of standardized gutta-percha, ensured more effective hydraulics during obturation. Today, the selection of the correct master cone has been simplified because of the rediscovery of system-based endodontics. System-based master cones streamline treatment in that they are intended to have an apical diameter the same as and a rate of taper slightly less than the largest sized manual or mechanically driven file that was carried to the full working length.
The master cone is fit in a fluid-filled canal to more closely simulate the lubrication effect that sealer will provide when sliding the buttered master cone into the prepared canal. Further, the master cone should be able to be inserted to the full working length and exhibit apical tugback upon removal. This master cone can be apically trimmed and further customized with glass slabs or a spatula, utilizing either cold or heat rolling techniques. It is simple to fit a master cone into a patent, smoothly tapered, and well-prepared canal.
A diagnostic working film should confirm the desired position of the master cone and verify all the previous operative steps. The master cone is typically cut back about one mm from the radiographic terminus, so that its most apical end is just short of the “apical constriction” or the actual position of the physiologic terminus (PT) (Figure 5). Specifically, the final length of any given prepared and finished canal is the reproducible distance from the reference point to the PT. Fortuitously, the position of the most apically instrumented foramen can be consistently located utilizing the paper point drying technique.12
Four manual pluggers (DENTSPLY Tulsa) utilized to compact heat-softened gutta-percha provide working end diameters of 0.5 mm, 0.7 mm, 0.9 mm, and 1.3 mm. Generally, a larger-sized plugger is selected that will work loosely, yet efficiently, over a range of a few millimeters in the coronal one third of the canal. A medium-sized plugger is selected that will work passively and effectively over a range of a few millimeters in the middle one third of the canal. In longer roots, a smaller-sized plugger may be required to work deeper and safely to within 5 mm of the canal terminus. Prefitting pluggers is essential and guarantees that when a plugger meets resistance, the plugger is on thermosoftened gutta-percha and not binding against unyielding dentinal walls.
SEALER AND MASTER CONE PLACEMENT
Kerr Pulp Canal Sealer EWT (Extended Working Time) (Henry Schein, Patterson Dental, or Benco Dental) has been specifically formulated for the warm gutta-percha with vertical condensation technique and affords several advantages.13
- Superior lubrication and flow
- Adjustable viscosity
- Dimensionally inert
- Essentially nonresorbable
- Sets in the presence of heat
- Inhibits prostaglandins
A fresh mix of Kerr Pulp Canal Sealer EWT completely sets extraorally within 30 minutes. Intraorally, this sealer sets even more rapidly, which advantageously serves to reduce an inflammatory postobturation response directly related to a sealer puff or surplus material after filling.
The amount of sealer used in this obturation technique should be minimal. Postobturation histological sections demonstrate wall-to-wall gutta-percha within the preparation and a thin 7 to 9 µm film of sealer occupying the dentin-gutta percha interface.14 An ultrathin film of sealer is desirable and has been shown to be significantly less predisposed to washing out.13 As an example, any single-cone filling technique undesirably relies on “pools” of sealer to fill the space between the master cone and the dentin interface. It is illogical to assume that these cones, over their length, closely approximate the actual cross-sectional anatomy of any given canal following preparation. Regrettably, over time the volume of the pools or lakes of cement are predisposed to shrink and dissolve, inviting microleakage and failure.4,13
The radicular portion of the master cone is lightly buttered with sealer, and then gently swirled as it is slowly slid to length. Placing the master cone in this manner will serve to more evenly distribute sealer along the walls of the preparation and, importantly, allow surplus sealer to harmlessly vent coronally. To be confident that there is sufficient sealer, the master cone is removed and its radicular surfaces inspected to ensure it is evenly coated with sealer. If the master cone is devoid of sealer, then simply rebutter and reinsert this cone to ensure there is sufficient sealer present. When the master cone is evenly coated with sealer and fully seated, obturation can commence.
CALAMUS DUAL 3-D OBTURATION SYSTEM
The Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System is one unit that conveniently combines both Calamus “Pack” and Calamus “Flow” handpieces (Figure 3). The Calamus Pack handpiece is the heat source that, in conjunction with an appropriately sized electric heat plugger (EHP), is utilized to thermosoften, remove, and condense gutta-percha during the downpacking phase of obturation. There are 3 variably sized EHPs and the one selected is based on the apical size, taper, and curvature of the finished preparation. The EHPs are available in ISO colors black, yellow, and blue, corresponding to working end diameters and tapers of 40/03, 50/05, and 60/06, respectively (Figure 6). The Calamus Pack handpiece also accepts a “thermal response tip” for conducting a diagnostic “hot test” on heat-sensitive pulps.
The Calamus Flow handpiece is utilized, in conjunction with a one-piece gutta-percha cartridge and integrated canula, to dispense warm gutta-percha into the preparation during the backpacking phase of obturation. The cartridges are single patient use and are available in 20 and 23 gauge sizes. The Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System provides a “bending tool” that may be utilized to place a smooth curvature on the canula. Ultimately, the gauge selected and the curvature placed should allow the canula to pass through the coronal two thirds of the preparation and to contact the previously downpacked master cone. As an alternative to the Calamus Dual 3D Obturation System, the Calamus Pack and the Calamus Flow handpieces are available as standalone obturation devices.
In preparation for initiating the downpack, the clinician should select the Calamus EHP that fits passively through the straightaway portion of the preparation and optimally to within 5 mm from the terminus of the canal (Figure 6). When the EHP cannot reach this desired level in a well-shaped canal, the Calamus bending tool may be utilized to place a suitable curvature on the more apical portion of the 40/03 EHP that matches the curvature of the prepared canal. A silicone stop may be placed on the EHP to safely monitor its maximum depth of insertion. Because of the thermomolecular properties of gutta-percha, the Calamus EHP will generate about a 5 mm heat wave through gutta-percha, apical to its actual depth of placement. Following the placement of the sealer-buttered master cone in a canal with an irregular cross-section, it is beneficial to inject heat-softened gutta-percha lateral to the master cone. This method will advantageously serve to initially thermosoften the master cone, maximize the volume of gutta-percha, and effectively increase hydraulics when commencing with the downpacking phase of obturation.
Figure 7a. Activate the Calamus Pack handpiece, sear off the nonuseful portion of the master cone, and note the transfer of heat through the gutta-percha.
Figure 7b. A large prefit plugger generates the first wave of condenstation (WOC) and automatically compacts warm gutta-percha vertically and laterally into the root canal system.
|Figure 8a. Upon activation, plunge the EHP 3 to 4 mm into the previously compacted material, deactivate, then remove, along with a “bite” of gutta-percha.||Figure 8b. The medium prefit plugger carries a second wave of condensation deeper into the progressively narrowing and tapering preparation.|
The Calamus EHP is activated and utilized to sear off the master cone at the CEJ in single-rooted teeth or at the orifice level in multirooted teeth (Figure 7a). To capture the maximum cushion of warm rubber, the working end of the large-sized prefit plugger is methodically stepped around the circumference of the canal. This plugger is used with short, firm, vertical strokes to scrape warm gutta-percha off the canal walls and flatten the material coronally. The working end of the plugger is used to vertically press on this flattened platform of warm gutta-percha for 5 seconds (Figure 7b). This action serves to automatically fill the root canal system, laterally and vertically, over a range of a few millimeters and is termed a wave of condensation (WOC).4 Specifically, a WOC moves thermosoftened gutta-percha into the narrowing cross-sectional diameters of the preparation, generates a piston effect on the entrapped sealer, and produces significant hydraulics. During this heating and compaction cycle, the operator will tactilely feel the warm mass of gutta-percha begin to stiffen as it cools. Importantly, using a plugger to press on warm gutta-percha during the cooling cycle has been shown to completely offset shrinkage.
To generate a progressively deeper heat wave along the length of the master cone, the Calamus EHP is activated and allowed to plunge 3 mm to 4 mm into the previously compacted material. Following the plunge, the EHP is deactivated and the operator should hesitate (a brief second) before removing the cooling instrument along with a “bite” of gutta-percha (Figure 8a). Removing a bite of gutta-percha results in the progressive apical transfer of heat another 4 mm to 5 mm along the length of the master cone and facilitates the placement of the medium-sized prefit plugger deeper into the root canal preparation. This plugger is used, as described above, to compact warm gutta-percha into this region of the canal, producing a second wave of condensation (Figure 8b).
|Figure 9a. Activate the EHP and plunge deeper into the gutta-percha; deactivate; then, remove the cooling EHP along with another bite of gutta-percha.||
Figure 9b. The working end of the small prefit plugger scrapes the walls of the canal clean, maximizes the volume of gutta-percha, and generates the final WOC.
Figure 10. Following the downpack, a working film demonstrates 3-D corkage and filled lateral canals coronal to the more apical mass of gutta-percha.
Depending on the length of the canal, only 2, 3, or 4 heating and removal cycles are required until the pre-selected EHP can be placed within 5 mm of the canal terminus (Figure 9a). Due to multiple heatings, thermal cycling progressively transfers heat into the apical one third of the gutta-percha master cone. Advantageously, the temperature of gutta-percha only has to be elevated 3º C above body temperature to become heat-softened and readily moldable. Utilizing this technique, obturation temperatures within the gutta-percha have been shown to be clinically safe and generate working temperatures that range from 40º C to 45º C. Fortuitously, the temperature produced on the external root surface is less than 2º C. This minor transfer of temperature is related to the fact that dentin is a poor conductor of heat; further, moisture within the PDL serves to wick off excessive heat.
Due to the efficient transfer of heat into the apical extent of the gutta-percha master cone, the small-sized prefit plugger need not be placed closer than 5 mm from the canal terminus. This plugger is stepped around the circumference of the canal to maximize the volume of gutta-percha available to achieve optimal hydraulics. A sustained 5-second vertical press with this plugger will deliver a controlled, thermosoftened wave of warm gutta-percha into the narrowing cross-sectional diameters of the prepared canal and result in apical corkage (Figure 9b). Again, a sustained 5-second press with this small-sized prefit plugger serves to offset shrinkage during the cooling cycle. Following the downpack, a working film frequently reveals filled accessory canals coronal to the more apical mass of gutta-percha (Figure 10). When the root canal has been properly shaped and the root canal system cleaned, then the material occupying the lateral anatomy may be all gutta-percha, or all sealer, but is typically a mixture of both.
Figure 11a. The tip of the warm Calamus Flow canula serves to rethermosoften the coronal most aspect of the previously packed gutta-percha.
Figure 11b. Press the activation cuff on the Calamus Flow handpiece and dispense a small 2 to 3 mm segment of warm gutta-percha into this region of the canal.
Figure 11c. The small prefit plugger is used to condense warm gutta-percha and generate a reverse WOC.
When the downpack has been completed and the apical one third corked, reverse filling the canal is important to eliminate radicular dead space. The Calamus Flow reverse filling technique, or what is termed the backpack, is easy, fast, and 3-D.
Thermosoftened gutta-percha is readily dispensed into a shaped canal utilizing the Calamus Flow handpiece in conjunction with a 20- or 23-gauge cartridge. A new cartridge is selected and inserted into the heating chamber and secured by tightening the cartridge nut. A protective heat shield may be used to prevent inadvertent thermal injury and is inserted over the canula and the heating chamber portion of the handpiece prior to backfilling the canal. When the Calamus Flow handpiece is activated, an internal plunger travels toward the heating chamber and the cartridge, which is filled with gutta-percha. In this manner, the plunger serves to push thermosoftened material out of the heated cartridge, through the canula, and into the canal.
The tip of the warm canula is positioned against the downpacked gutta-percha for 5 seconds to rethermosoften its most coronal extent (Figure 11a). This procedural nuance promotes cohesion between each injected segment of warm gutta-percha. The Calamus Flow handpiece is activated, and a short 2 mm to 3 mm segment of warm gutta-percha is dispensed into the most apical region of the empty canal (Figure 11b). Injecting or dispensing too much gutta-percha invites shrinkage and/or voids which result in poorly obturated canals judged radiographically. The Calamus Flow handpiece should be held lightly so it will “back out” of the canal when injecting thermosoftened gutta-percha into the canal. The small-sized prefit plugger is used, as previously described, to densely compact warm gutta-percha into this region of the canal. Utilizing the plugger in this manner will capture the maximum cushion of rubber, promote successful hydraulics, and generate “reverse” waves of condensation (Figure 11c).
Figure 12a. The Calamus Flow handpiece is activated and a longer, 3 to 4 mm segment of warm gutta-percha is dispensed into this region of the canal.
Figure 12b. A medium-sized prefit plugger densely compacts warm gutta-percha vertically and laterally into this region of the canal.
Figure 13. This graphic illustrates that the potential to fill root canal systems is largely dependent on shaping canals and 3-D cleaning.
To continue the backfilling technique, dispense a longer, 3 to 4 mm segment of warm gutta-percha into this more coronal region of the canal (Figure 12a). The working end of the medium-sized prefit plugger is stepped circumferentially around the preparation to clean the dentinal walls, flatten the dispensed material, and deliver warm gutta-percha, laterally and vertically, into this region of the canal. This plugger is used to press against the cooling gutta-percha for 5 seconds to offset shrinkage during the cooling phase (Figure 12b). The backfilling technique continues, in the manner described, until the canal has been reverse filled (Figure 13). Alternatively, backfilling may be stopped at any level within the canal to accommodate a post to facilitate potential restorative needs.
To fill furcal canals, the pulp chamber floor of multirooted teeth is covered with a thin layer of sealer prior to dispensing gutta-percha. An appropriately sized amalgam plugger is used to effectively compact thermosoftened gutta-percha on the pulpal floor, which in turn generates desirable hydraulics. Different horizontally angulated post-treatment radiographs may be taken to confirm that the root canal system has been densely obturated, laterally and vertically, to the canal terminus (Figure 14). Frequently, a puff of sealer will be noticed adjacent to a portal of exit and should be considered irrelevant to the prognosis of the case. When the prepared apical foramen is relatively round, and if the master cone has been well-fitted, sealer puffs will generally be larger laterally, and smaller or nonexistent apically.
|Figure 14. Complete endodontic treatment provides a predictably successful foundation for perioprosthetics.|
Following obturation procedures, gutta-percha and sealer are thoroughly excavated from the pulp chamber, utilizing a solvent such as xylol or chloroform. A solution of 70% isopropyl alcohol is flushed into the pulp chamber to remove any obturation residues in preparation for the restorative effort. Scientific evidence has shown that flushing out the chamber as described will eliminate free eugenol and allow for predictably successful bonding.15
The Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System is innovative technology that may be utilized to fill root canal systems. As the health of the attachment apparatus associated with endodontically treated teeth becomes fully understood and completely appreciated, the naturally retained root will be recognized as the “ultimate dental implant.” When properly performed, endodontic treatment is one of the cornerstones of restorative and reconstructive dentistry.
- Ruddle, CJ. Calamus Directions for Use. Advanced Endodontics, Santa Barbara, CA, 2009. endoruddle.com/information.html?name=PDFS.
- Ruddle CJ. The ProTaper technique. Endodontic Topics. 2005;10:187-190.
- Ruddle CJ. Endodontic disinfection: tsunami irrigation. Endodontic Practice. 2008;11:7-15.
- Schilder H. Filling root canals in three dimensions. Dent Clin North Am. November 1967:723-744.
- Ruddle CJ. Ruddle on Shape•Clean•Pack [DVD]. Santa Barbara, Calif: Advanced Endodontics, 2008.
- Marlin J, Schilder H. Physical properties of gutta-percha when subjected to heat and vertical condensation. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1973;36:872-879.
- Gurney BF, Best EJ, Gervasio G. Physical measurements on gutta-percha. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1971;32:260-270.
- Goodman A, Schilder H, Aldrich W. The thermomechanical properties of gutta-percha. II. The history and molecular chemistry of gutta-percha. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1974;37:954-961.
- Schilder H, Goodman A, Aldrich W. The thermomechanical properties of gutta-percha. III. Determination of phase transition temperatures for gutta-percha. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1974;38:109-114.
- Goodman A, Schilder H, Aldrich W. The thermomechanical properties of gutta-percha. IV. A thermal profile of the warm gutta-percha packing procedure. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol. 1981;51:544-551.
- Ruddle CJ. Three-dimensional obturation of the root canal system. Dent Today. 1992;11:28,30-33,39.
- Ruddle CJ. Three-dimensional obturation: the rationale and application of warm gutta percha with vertical condensation. In: Cohen S, Burns RC. Pathways of the Pulp. 6th ed. St. Louis, Mo: Mosby Yearbook Co; 1994.
- Casanova F. Understanding Some Clinically Significant Physical Properties of Kerr Sealer Through Investigation [thesis]. Boston, Mass: Boston University; 1975.
- Ruddle CJ. An In Vitro Scanning Electron Microscope Study of the Warm Gutta Percha With Vertical Condensation Technique [thesis]. Boston, Mass: Harvard School of Dental Medicine; 1976.
- Southard DW. Immediate core buildup of endodontically treated teeth: the rest of the seal. Pract Periodontics Aesthet Dent. 1999;11:519-526.
Dr. Ruddle is founder and director of Advanced Endodontics in Santa Barbara, Calif. He also maintains a private practice in Santa Barbara. He is an assistant professor of Graduate Endodontics at Loma Linda University and University of California, Los Angeles, is an associate clinical professor at University of California, San Francisco, and is an adjunct assistant professor of Endodontics at University of the Pacific, School of Dentistry. Dr. Ruddle has designed and developed several instruments and devices that are widely used internationally. He can be reached at (800) 753-3636 or endoruddle.com.
Disclosure: Dr. Ruddle has a financial interest in products he designs and develops, including the Calamus Dual 3-D Obturation System.